Case Study 1
Ten partner firm finds target firm is insolvent
Our client was a significant single office full service high street firm with 10 equity partners based in a County town. It was reasonably profitable with PEP in the low £100,000s and had a number of market leading niche services for its location. Strategically it had decided to seek a merger with a view to strengthening and its existing service offering while adding other additional disciplines. As it had a high market share in its existing location it was agreed to approach what were perceived like minded firms in another similar sized geographical location. Having identified such a firm the instructions from the managing partner was that our role was to act as Lead Advisors with a view to concluding a merger.
As we had not been involved in the strategic decision making we needed to bring ourselves quickly up to speed on the relative financial position of each firm and to understand the rationale for the merger from each firm’s perspective. It very quickly became clear that the respective managing partners of each firm had had very limited discussions of a substantive nature and in particular had not:
- Identified who was the stronger party i.e. who was acquiring who
- Identified the true value of each firm
- The financial position of each firm
- Whether there was a consensus on the basis of sharing profits in the merged firm
- Crucially the borrowing levels that would be necessary on merger and the increased bank debt that our client would have to absorb
It became clear very quickly that:
- The target firm was insolvent and was in the final stages of their banks “special measures” department which had involved an Independent Business Review (IBR) and that their bank was pressing for a merger as a solution
- The target firm were in denial as to the seriousness of their position
- The managing partner of our client had, what one of his senior partners described to us later as “the merger bug” and had neither fully involved his partners nor did he have their support.
Suffice it to say that the merger talks were called off but at the expense of the managing partner’s position and much angst, wasted management time and expense. All of this could have been avoided by an early involvement of a Lead Advisor and the formation of a merger sub-committee of partners.